Five Eclipse Novel Scenes that Must be in the Movie

482 Comments July 30, 2009 by Will Filed Under: Commentary

Eclipse 200907301415 Five Eclipse Novel Scenes that Must be in the Movie commentary Reelz has collected five scenes from the book Eclipse that they think must be in the movie. They include character flashbacks and Chapter 22, Fire and Ice, but here is one I can’t wait for–

Chapter 15 “Wager” This chapter has everything: Jacob kissing Bella against her wishes, Bella punching Jacob and breaking her hand, and Edward gallantly stepping up to defend his woman. Here’s hoping Melissa Rosenberg writes this whole chapter into the screenplay — especially Edward’s “If you ever kiss her again, I will break your jaw for her” line. There’s no doubt about it: Theater audiences would swoon.

[thanks Spunkie!]

Category: Commentary

hey_I_read (hitches and tents)

Haha, I like it, Twipot, cleaver. It does look freaky. I guess I am going to give up and go to bed. I will talk to you this weekend sometime!

________________________________
hey_I_read (hitches and tents)

I agree completely!! Those are all great scenes!! I love the top ten nights, and possessive Edward! Fire and Ice = hottness and a happy me!!

________________________________
hey_I_read (hitches and tents)

I agree completely!! Those are all great scenes!! I love the top ten nights, and possessive Edward! Fire and Ice = hottness and a happy me!!

________________________________
ohmy_feathers ♥ TNV

Wow did this just post again for no reason? LOL!
ohmy_feathers ♥ TNV

Wow did this just post again for no reason? LOL!
David Slade rocks!!

lol they have to be in the film plus peter Facinelli said in an interview yesterday that we will see the big battle on the screen as well as the one with Victoria and Edward
David Slade rocks!!

lol they have to be in the film plus peter Facinelli said in an interview yesterday that we will see the big battle on the screen as well as the one with Victoria and Edward
RobismyRomeo (RIMR)

lol, yes! I just now found it!

And scarlet was such a dear to have found me on twitter and alerted me of said party. Ok.. so we're are throwing a party for you this Friday. Let's make it a costume party!

You decide what kind of costume/theme.. when and where.. and I will get started!

:0)
4thewolf

OMgosh!! RISMR.. a costume party!!! For me????

Thank you so much!! *eyes go softy*

Umm.. I'm not sure costume-wise how you want to go..you decide, but I LOVE LOVE LOVE.. pretty dresses (thinks back to fact that 4TW is constantly threatening and beating ppl up) Uh..yeah.. wierd.. right? LOL .. We could have a masked ball!!!!! *gets excited* Or anyone could wear thier choice of costume, but have some sort of half-mask.. I don't know..

*face falls*

I'm better at impromptu..

*sigh* You just tell me and we'll work with it. I'll think on it..

LOL
RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)

Yes! A big costume party, just in honor of your awesomeness!

Let's see.. let's see.. we'll do a masked ball- people can come as their favorite character -book, movie, comic, etc-

I'll wear a pretty dress with you- but my costume is a surprise! :0)

All shall reveal their costume at this time! What time works for you on Friday?
4thewolf

OOh, I don't know RISMR what time.. maybe 7:00 ish my time??

We'll work on that closer to time. just so long as my “real” life isn't' spinning out of control .LOL
RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)

LOL!! Ok.. I will work on that.. I don't have internet at home, so we'll see if I can't tweak my mobile internet to let me post comments on the NMM site!

I'm excited!
http://eclipsemovie.org/ team jacob 4 life

i would LOVE if slade ended the movie when jacob recives the letter from edward and runs away and the wolfs try to convince him not to go and the sam tells them to back off and tells jacob to come back soon and jacob pushes himself harder to escape the pain(and they could add somthing more like jacob saying somthing like how much he love bella or resiting the poem ‘fire or ice’
http://eclipsemovie.org/ team jacob 4 life

love the whole jacob scenes ; )
twiborn

lol…..thats hilarious haha….i remember that (i hope they make emmett goofier)
twiborn

*stands behind TCW with a shovel*

and I'm behind you!
twiborn

lol “angry grizzly bears are gonna look tame next to what is waiting for you at home” lmao….thats hilarious!!!
twiborn

i would like that scene in eclipse when bella is upset at edward (phonecall scene) lol……angry grizzly bears are gonna look tame next to what is waiting for you at home…..omg another one of my favorite scenes, (bella finally shows the mad woman in her!!! lol)
Featherheaven

Love that line!! then Alice says “This hostage stuff is fun!” LOL
twiborn

lmao haha…i couldn't stop laughing (i admit…ive read that part like 100 times!)
hey_I_read

Oh yes, that scene is awesome!! It is even better when he gets home and crawls in bed expecting her wrath!! *wink*

________________________________
Featherheaven

Ya one of my favorite parts of the book!!
twiborn

haha!!!
Anonymous

ahh Eclipse I can’t waittt! I think it may be my favorite out of the four.
even though it makes me sad, because I feel bad for Jake.
I love how I can never decide who I’d rather Bella be with.
Anonymous

ahh Eclipse I can’t waittt! I think it may be my favorite out of the four.
even though it makes me sad, because I feel bad for Jake.
I love how I can never decide who I’d rather Bella be with.
Twi-Tiana_7

i agree with all the scenes you have said….especially when edward and bella have the house tothem selves its the best and my favorite scene!!
a scene im not lookin froward too wld have to be after Jacob and Bella kiss by the tent…by the by i utterly hated her at that second i dnt know if its was because i envyed her or was just extremely pissed she did that to Edward. But when Edward says ” I can be noble, Bella. I'm not going to make you choose between us. Just be happy, and you can have whatever part of me you want, or none at all, if that's better. Don't let any debt you feel you owe me influence your decision.'” that rite there kills me inside and out!!!! ugh sry for my rant but that part just gets me everytime i hate it too see Edward so nice but still in so much pain!
Kim1524 (Fanfic Junkie)

These are some of my favourite scenes, so hopefully they will be there! Especially the “I will break your jaw for her” line, hotnes!!
http://Savageoriginals.com Savageo

If you remember Bella had left Edward a telephone message about his method of trying to keep her safe while he was hunting…. “You are in trouble, Enormous trouble. angry grizzly bears are going to look tame next to what is waiting for you at home.” So even though she had been with Jacob and was afraid of how mad he'd be, Edward also was in the “dog house” (sorry about that). It really was a very sweet scene when they got back together.
Anonymous

They must have the scene of when Jacob keeps Bella warm and she falls asleep while Edward reads Jacob’s mind the whole scene was intriging i cant wait to see it. i hope they dont stop either they must film Breaking Dawn!!
hilighter

OK, while we're confessing, not only have I read these damn books repeatedly (which i have never done before with any other book), I was pathetic enough to go buy the audio versions, downloaded to my Ipod and listen in the car, and before i go to bed.. I NEED HELP!!!!
hey_I_read

Haha, it is ok! I tried the audio (itunes offered free chap from NM) but I didn't like hearing that woman's voice read it. For some reason, I only like hearing it with my voice! haha I did download the movie and bonus discs and NM trailer to my Iphone though! Always have it handy whenever I need a fix!! Not to even mention the fanfics! haha

________________________________
ineedluv

**clears throat also** guilty I read it over and over its cemented in my memory.. sexy.. I think its the sexiest part of the saga..
**slaps face**
got lost in thoughts of 'wide awake' leg hitch..
**all hot and sweaty now**
*need a drink and a lie down**
hey_I_read

haha, the leg hitch is a popular theme around these parts! Be careful saying the title to that fanfic, you may get modded!

________________________________
ineedluv

***holds hand out to be slapped***
I don't normally put the title just got lost in the moment
bad girl..

cheers for that
hey_I_read

ROFL! good girl, we must all play by the rules! haha

________________________________
cronan

I saw that too and its awful. She loks like a man…

should have just got a pic of bryce from silent hill. Rachelle and Bryce are built differently and even their shade of red is different.

I just hope that summit does away with the wigs in eclipse and forces the actors to either cut their hair or have extensions put in.
TeamEdwardForever101 (TEF)

The Scenes-

1. The Charlie and Bella “Talk”
2.Jacksonville
(Sorry out of order)
3.Chapter 22, Fire and Ice, for sure
4.Chapter 15,Wager, for sure
5.When Edward and Bella Make-out on the couch- THE LEG HITCH!!!
6.The Proposal
7.The Meadow scene at the end
8.Rosalie & Jaspers Stories

Just please, please, please put all the scenes in!
bina209

man im just waiting for eclipes it my FAVORITE book, i hope they dont leave out the important scenes in the movie!!!!
MillyPattinson

definately those scenes
in particular 1 (its just so funny), 3, 4, 5 (ahhhh the leg hitch i love that bit) and the meadow scene .
arghhh im so excited for this film now even though its agessss away
MillyPattinson

definately need to put this in, its my favourite part of the book.

i just read that little passage there about 4 times before commenting
MillyPattinson – Flippy (L)

urgh i hate it when he threatens to kill himself. he would never have done that he was just being manipulating. ever since i read that i hated jacob, hes so conceted, and self righteous.
MillyPattinson – Flippy (L)

urgh i hate it when he threatens to kill himself. he would never have done that he was just being manipulating. ever since i read that i hated jacob, hes so conceted, and self righteous.
MillyPattinson – Flippy (L)

urgh i hate it when he threatens to kill himself. he would never have done that he was just being manipulating. ever since i read that i hated jacob, hes so conceted, and self righteous.
TeamEdwardForever101 (TEF)

Yes- Ahhhh the wonderfully beautiful leg hitch!

Don't say that! It's only……

*Counts on fingers*

103 days, 13 hours and 39 minutes as of right now!

Thats not that long right?! Right?!

*Starts freaking out* LOL
TeamKristen(L)RumpyPumpy

As long as 165-167 is in the film and the meadow at the end and the proposal then i will be one happy happy girl.
daysknowitall

Another, not as goody good as the hitch but did make my skin crawl, was the one where she sneaks to see Jacob while Edward is on the hunt and she is suppose to goto a friends house to help with invitations to graduation. Bell knows she has to hurry b/c of Alice but that she'll make it when she is in Alice's blind spot. She knows Edward is gonna be furious so when she leaves Jacob she looks in her rear view and bam, there is Edwards car right behind her as soon as she is out of the wolf zone. He never gets out but revs his engine as he passes her when she gets to the friends house. Nothing is ever said between Edward n Bella during the scene but you can feel the chills and you know she's gonna get the wrath from Edward and Bella knows it too!
Teren

you and me think alot a like!!! my fav is when edward comes back from hunting that ENTIRE part is amazing ahhhhh! and i totally feel bad for edward during the tent scene GRRRR! and yes the end part w/ bella & eward in the meadow yumm!!
RMD

I agree, that should be in there. How else could his abscece in the beginning of BD be explained?
http://twitter.com/sofiad89 im_switzerland

that was HOT! I can't wait!!!
http://twitter.com/sofiad89 im_switzerland

to mE the sexiest part was the night the got engaged!!!<333 totally hot!

oh, and when he takes her to the meadow at the end.