Is Breaking Dawn in 3D a Good Idea?

645 Comments February 16, 2010 by MrsEdwardCullen Filed Under: Fans, Featured News, Must See

Eclipse breaking dawn l Is Breaking Dawn in 3D a Good Idea? must see featured news fans

Anything Breaking Dawn is a good idea, so get on with it already! Entertainment Weekly’s PopWatch has a poll determining what we the fans would want to see: The Twilight Saga:Breaking Dawn(goosebumps) in 3D or not so much? Here are the pros and cons.

Pro: For the studio, there’s the extra fee on the ticket, which is guaranteed to be a hot one for Twihards regardless of its decision. Also, the still rare 3D experience could lure in moviegoers who are on the fence.
Con: For the person who sees the Twilight films purely to keep current on pop culture, having to pay more will heighten any resentment he or she may feel if disappointed.

Pro: Fast-moving vampires and werewolves should look awesome in 3D. So should Bella and Edward getting busy…
Con: Shockingly, some Twilight fans don’t want to feel like they’re in the room (or water) for those intimate moments.

At this point who cares! Give it the green light already, I don’t know about you guys, but I’m starting to develop a serious high blood pressure condition thanks to Summit. Check out PopWatch Poll to vote and to read the hilarious Tweets from fans about their views on 3D ‘leg hitches’.

(Source Thanks, CF!)

Category: Fans, Featured News, Must See

C shell – Team Kristen

Yeah! She e-mailed me. My campus is only about an hour or less from where she is.
My hometown is 8 hours away from here though so I won't always be this close, but it's pretty cool anyways.
C shell – Team Kristen

I wish! I'd do so much better on it than I think I'm going to do on this one… yikes.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

What are you studying? It does eat your time up,doesn't it?
C shell – Team Kristen

Aw okay! Hey, all of us are off and on the site, so it's all good if she's busy. I try to sneak on here all of the time even when I can't sit down and really chat. I think we all do that.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Awww, that is cool. It's nice to know stuff like that,I think. I feel like I know you guys as if I've already known you, it's wierd. But ,like I told TD I feel a bond. I love it.
C shell – Team Kristen

Community Studies, social movements and art practice.
It's kind of an intersection of different things, like sociology, politics, and art history…
C shell – Team Kristen

I know! Me too. I love having a twi-fam.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

That's what I told her.That's 99 per cent of us. LOL But I'll keep talkin to her,maybe she'll come in later. Yeah look at you ,studying and stff,TD has to tend her little ones,we all have things that keep us off, but we catch up,even if for a few minutes. Better than nothing.
C shell – Team Kristen

Yeah! And nem is studying medicine, isn't she? Jeez, I aspire to be like her.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

I really do,too. That's what it seems like ,too. A family on line. Twifam—I like. All sorts of twi's huh? Hey it started the whole thing,so yeah there need to be lots of twi's. twi-fam,twi-hards,twi-fans,yeah
C shell – Team Kristen

It's way better than nothing! I love checking in with you guys and catching up in the twi universe. It's a nice way to end the day and check out of the real world for a bit.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Yeah, nem is in medicine,although I'm not sure in which capacity. Next time I talk I'm going to ask her. Miss that little gal. She's sweet.All my sisters are exceptionally sweet. Are you going into medicine,too?
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Yeah,it is. A few minutes keeps you tuned in to this fabulous world.
C shell – Team Kristen

No, I'm not on the right path and my mind does not do that well with math and science… my aunts and uncles are doctors but it's not in the cards for me!

And I know, nem's fun. She always has something up her sleeve. Whether it's Robfetti or her plan for us the day we get an Eclipse trailer and the site is inundated with thousands of fans going nuts… smoke signals and everything to find us in the chaos.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Sweetheart math has always been by bug-a boo. Ewwww, I hated math.Science, not so bad.
Do you know what you want to do,yet? That's kinda scarey. Some people know what they want to do, I thought I wanted to be a nurse, til I worked in a hospital Medical Records Dept and saw all the ER's come in. I don't mind blood or anything,but if they were hurting or a child came in ,I couldn't take it. so then I didn't know what I wanted,so I just worked for a while . I regret not taking up something. But back then, I didn't know what I wanted to do. It works out, but I wish I had something under my belt. LOL
C shell – Team Kristen

I know, I hate math too but I like science… just not so easy for me.
Wow, I can't imagine working in a hospital! I have zero tolerance for blood… it makes me squirm. The first time that I watched Twilight and watched Edward suck the poison out of Bella's arm in the ballet studio, I seriously thought I was going to faint. I had to look away!

I know what I want to do, we'll just see if it happens… hehe. Ready for this? I want to do some sort of social documentation/storytelling, whether it's straight documentary film making or more creative interpretations of people's true stories. And I'm interested in under-represented communities. Pretty idealistic, I know…
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

hahaha, Bless your heart. Reminds me of Bella.
You sound very interprising,young lady and I admire you wanting to help with under-represented communities. Very impressive.
C shell – Team Kristen

Aw, thanks Vampie. That means a lot. I feel like most people just kind of shake their heads at me because it isn't automatically or necessarily lucrative like other career paths.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Hey, I'll tell you what I tell my grand daughter (she's in high school) Nope, I ain't an old goat, either. LOL I tell her to follow her dream. You sound a lot like her in wanting to help underprivileged parts of the country. If you love what you do, you will do well in it. If you hate it, you won't succeed,so what some people think is lucrative,may not be for another. Just study up on those types of interests and go with your heart. I think certain people are meant to do these types of jobs. Not everyone has the heart and mind to do it. Hang in there, honey.
C shell – Team Kristen

Ahhhhh, I love you Vampie! You're the best. Your grand daughter is so lucky to have you.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

I love you,too sweetie. I'm lucky to have all my sisters,too.
C shell – Team Kristen

I agree. I feel like I've known you guys for way longer than it's been!
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Ahh my sweet little Cshell, Vampie's gonna have to retire,hon. I feel tired now. Wish I had the Cullen never sleep thing. LOL I could talk to you til daybreak,but I know you have things you need to do ,too,hon. So I'll check for you on here tomorrow,for sure. Thanks for the chat. I have thoroughly enjoyed it. I feel I know you even more. You stay sweet. Love ya little gal *coven hugs and kiss on cheek*
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

I know,it really does. Other than not knowing what you guys look like, I know you. It's a real blessing
C shell – Team Kristen

Goodnight! *big hug* Thanks for staying on with me. I wish I had the Cullen never sleep thing too. I could use it to study! Sleep well, I'll see you around tomorrow.
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Goodnight ,and you're welcome., I have enjoyed it immensely. Thanks for the chat. xxx nitey nite
Lu :) SPIDERFLIPPY = LOVE.

Well, I give you permission to pester me until I give it to you!
[Rob bite my pillows!] <3

I'm always okay in Rob's presence ! But I would be much better if they just stop all that 3D nonsense. Just give me Rob. Ill save a seat for him in the cinema – or we can share mine
[Rob bite my pillows!] <3

Thank you.. ill remember that and about Valentines day. I think you should go and see it. It's really Sweet. Plus Taylor is in it Woow I never thought that would be a reason to go see a movie …
Anonymous

hehe the pros and cons made me lol i wouldn’t mind it either way
VAMPLOVER CarolinaCullenCoven

Amen ,little twipal.
Anonymous

O.k!
Personaly I tink this whole 3D thing is just stupid…
Why would the 4th movie be in 3d than the other?
A 3D Rob and Taylor…Yes But Ask yourself this….
Is it wroth my money to spend for a crappy breaking dawn…?
Or the F***ing BEST MOVIE IN THE WORLD!…?

I think wait is just the exicting part of this twilight saga…..
But that’s just me..

But I do think that Summit is going a little to far with this whole
thing.

Frist,They dont HAVE A DRICTOR YET!
Second,They have not idea what they should do for Renesme
Third,Tey might lose a lot of money oing 3D and
Lose many of Fans IF THAT MOVIE ISNT PREFECT!!!!!!

Ladies,what is your opion?
seriouslysoobsessed

haha..awesome. it's seriously going to be really exciting to see how they interpret it. it's not gonna be easy..how else could they do it without going 3D you know?
Lu :) SPIDERFLIPPY = LOVE.

Hahaaa. The twi-gods have changed you .. How much is he in it though? cause looking at the trailer it really doesn't seem like that much….
Iweby

Thank you!!!!
At least someone understands….
I think the same way…A 3d Rob or Taylor would be
nice but I rather spend my money on A good Breaking Dawn
Moive than a chessy pice of Crap.Right?
And what about the whole Real Nessie or not…

That's Jut crap…What your opion?
Iweby

What wrong with Melissa Rosenbreg?
Plus what is better spending money on
a crap 3d Bre3aking movie or the best
Breaking Dawn moive ever…

And they cant make it rated R because there
to many teen fans that cant wach rated R in theaters….
Gaby ( around april/ 09 )

Melissa Rosenberg destroyed Twilight PERIOD.
twlgtfan

Umm I think the Twilight saga is already as commercial as you can get there is nothing Indie really about it but with saying that at the same time it totally deserves its popularity too since the books and are amazingly written and New Moon was very well done in comparison to the first movie. I agree with the comment that with the right director it could be really good in 3D however I also think that it should be made in both versions and that perhaps some parts could be left out of the 3D imaging like the birth scene.
twlgtfan

At least it wasn't as rushed as Twilight but yes it should follow the books since I'm sure none of us would mind sitting in the movie longer anyhow. But I suppose they probably have a time limit.
http://www.fanfiction.com/~youroasis MCNutters [Team Nessie!]

twilight felt right to me i think.

what if they dont have a time limit? LOTR and HP movies are each 3-4 hrs long. and the books are as long as SM's.
[Rob bite my pillows!] <3

Hmm.. it's not a movie with ONE lead role.. It's alot of persons you follow, therefor not ONE plot, but many.. He's in like 2 or 3 scenes, but almost just as many as the other actors.. No of course he isn't one of the leading roles.. And yes the twi-gods have changed me indeed !!
http://twitter.com/cjean_ Cjean loves Bel Ami Rob

I completely agree. There are WAY more imporant things to worry about than the 3D. I really, realy hope BD will turn out right. There are so many ways that the movie could be made wrong.
http://twitter.com/cjean_ Cjean loves Bel Ami Rob

Haha! The sad thing is that Summit probably would have flying birds in your face. lol
http://twitter.com/cjean_ Cjean loves Bel Ami Rob

Yep! I agree 100 percent! Twi in 3D is too much, it's like they are trying too hard..
Jennifer *Team Nov. 20th!!!*

Yes, definitely trying too hard! There was just something very cool about having Twilight be this not-so-mainstream type of film. The casting was incredible (my one and only thank you to CH) and it was nice to see some fresh faces and not the same ol' A-list actors. Yes, the cast is incredibly well-known now but I think the rest of the movies need to keep within the same spirit as Twilight was made. I don't think they need to go all crazy with stuff like 3D- we twihards will come out in droves to see the movies anyway! =). (As if that wasn't already evident enough with Twilight and New Moon!)